An absolute MUST READ from TechCrunch.com for anyone who even casually uses social media:
NSFW: After Fort Hood, another example of how ‘citizen journalists’ can’t handle the truth
by Paul Carr on November 7, 2009 [Excerpt]
I’d probably feel slightly smug, if I didn’t feel so sick.
Smug that after two weeks of me suggesting that social media might not be an unequivocally Good Thing in terms of privacy and human decency, the news has delivered the perfect example to support my view.
Unfortunately it’s hard to feel smug – hard to feel anything but sadness and nausea – when thirteen innocent people are dead.
I’m talking, of course, about Thursday’s Fort Hood shootings. Better informed and more sensitive commentators than I have written about the massacre itself and what it means for the US army, and in particular for the thousands of Muslim soldiers currently fighting – and dying – for this country. How do you even begin to process the idea of an American soldier shouting the takbir, before mowing down his comrades in arms? On American soil? At the home base of the Combat Warrior Stress Reset program? Yes, that’s definitely one for the experts to parse.
And yet, the first news and analysis out of the base didn’t come from the experts. Nor did it come from the 24-hour news media, or even from dedicated military blogs – but rather from the Twitter account of one Tearah Moore, a soldier from Linden, Michigan who is based at Fort Hood, having recently returned from Iraq.
[SZ: Please follow link to continue this important piece from Paul Carr. Yes, even if you are someone who rarely "clicks through" - it's THAT important.]
Social media is an evolving technology that we are adopting at a staggering pace. In many ways it opens the world to us and connects us with people we would not otherwise ever come to know, or contribute to our personal growth, even if it is only in some small measure.
Social media can keep us informed. It can entertain us. It can expand our personal horizons and potentials.
It can also be terribly destructive, harmful, and hurtful. I say that as someone who loves social media, as someone who considers herself a “citizen journalist” [via PandemicChronicle.com].
Another snippet from Paul Carr:
And that’s precisely the problem: none of us think we’re being selfish or egotistic when we tweet something, or post a video on YouTube or check-in using someone’s address on Foursquare. It’s just what we do now, no matter whether we’re heading out for dinner or witnessing a massacre on an Army base. Like Lord of the Flies, or the Stanford Prison Experiment
, as long as we’re all losing our perspective at the same time – which, as a generation growing up with social media we are – then we don’t realise that our humanity is leaking away until its too late.
The Stanford Prison Experiment he mentions and links to is also worth the time to read. I read it afresh, along with Philip Zimbardo’s The Lucifer Effect: Understanding How Good People Turn Evil because of my pandemic advocacy [of all things]. Carr’s reference was anything but casual or capricious.
So go read already….




V – We are of Peace
I finally had the opportunity to watch the new ABC show V today. I have to wait for ABC shows to become available on Hulu.com [don't ask] and today was the first day V’s pilot episode was available. A premier I eagerly awaited.
I am a stealth hardcore SciFi fan, something not exactly common for my demographic. Even given my already gleeful anticipation, the political junkie in me began to salivate when I read this piece from the Chicago Tribune:
Please do hop on over and read the entire article, regardless of your political “flavor” it offers some great insight, both into the show – and into our political hearts.
A funny thing though, in that sadly pathetic kind of way, is that there are people who really do believe the earth is infiltrated by “Reptilian aliens”, that they walk among us and are the puppeteers of the “power elite” of the world.
The show inspired a bit of personal discomfort when I realized that I would probably be one of the many who are hoodwinked in our fictitious television drama. I do believe that somewhere out there in the vastness of the universe other intelligent life exists. I believe that life, or some of it anyway, is vastly more advanced than we. And, I hope that they will one day introduce themselves to us – to our benefit.
A hope not unlike that of many religious folk who hope that the God of their understanding will come forth and set the world aright, right as judged by their beliefs that is. I don’t want aliens to come to earth and set us straight, to right all our wrongs, etc. I just think it would be cool in the extreme to know we are not alone and that there is hope that we will evolve past the “let’s kill each other” phase. Highly advanced, beneficent aliens would be affirmation that is possible, even if only remotely so.
A few years ago I asked myself if my wish for confirmation on advanced alien life [of the good kind] was, perhaps, inspired by my suspicions that human beings are genetically incapable of not bringing about our own mass extinction. My answer to myself: Probably. The history of the last few years has done nothing but reinforce that belief. It went from a vague suspicion to a rather well entrenched belief.
As such, as I said, I would no doubt be among the “adoring clueless”. But, I said the same thing to my husband the first time we watched Independence Day. I’d be like that exotic dancer that made a sign and went to a gathering at the top of a tall building to welcome the aliens — then the aliens vaporized the building just as the dancer realized the foolishness of her naivete.
But back to V. When things are tough and unpleasant we want someone to swoop in and make them all better. Who can argue that things are pretty tough and unpleasant for an awful lot of people? That alone was a large part of Obama’s mass appeal. Young, charismatic, attractive, he promised to sweep away all the old detritus and cut away all the dead tissue so healthy tissue [a healthy society, a "fair" society] could grow in its place. I won’t get into the stuff about all the broken promises and incompetence, as those are topics for another post. But, not only has he failed to make things better — he has made them worse, or empowered others to make things worse. Like humanity is scheduled to find out in V – the beneficent problem solvers are really here to eat us. You can’t get much worse than that.
Below is the pilot episode, embedded from Hulu.com just in case you haven’t seen it yet and are unfamiliar with how to navigate Hulu. By the way, Hulu is a wonderful thing indeed. I get to watch the other ABC show I’ve become hooked on this season, FlashForward. Both of these new shows have a lot to say about human psychology in the best traditions of fictional drama, and they’re entertaining to boot.